2019 Best Auto Insurance Companies

November 25, 2019

When it comes to auto insurance, you want to make sure you’re buying protection from the best companies out there. When you buy a high-quality policy from a reputable provider, you can rest easy know that you are protected.

Other than policies that can be tailored to your insurance needs, the best car insurance companies offer fantastic customer service, easy access to your policy details and a quick claims process.

We are highlighting some of the companies that received high ratings across the board in a  J.D. Power’s Auto Claims Satisfaction Study.


Progressive is one of the biggest insurance companies with high rated reviews. They come in extremely competitive when it comes to pricing, and other things. Their long lineup of discounts also make them an attractive choice to many buyers. Here are some facts about Progressive:

  • More than 18,000,000 drivers insured
  • Competitive rates and discounts ranging anywhere from safe driver, pay in full, multi-car, multi-policy, quoting online and more.
  • Name your price tool
  • Bundle auto and property to save $5
  • Snapshot program which personalizes your rates based on how you drive
  • Loan/lease payoff coverage, roadside assistance and strong financial ratings


You probably know GEICO from their lizard mascot. J.D. Power gave GEICO average to above average marks in every category. However, there are still benefits to having a policy plan through them.

  • Quote tool to determine how much you’ll pay for your plan.
  • Submit claim or make a payment through their website
  • Emergency roadside assistance
  • Breakdown coverage
  • Ridesharing insurance
  • Auto Repair Xpress

GEICO also offers discounts such as good student, good driver and more.

State Farm

State Farm has a history of financial stability and good customer service. State Farm is the number one writer of private passenger auto insurance, with over $40 million of premiums written.

  • Brick and mortar stores and agents
  • Many discounts offered
  • Great mobile app
  • Online quotes


Owned by Allstate, Esurance gives you the control and flexibility to build a policy that fits your needs. This company was one of the first companies that started selling directly to the customer instead of going through an agent.

Anyone can get a quote, as long as you have internet connection.

  • Very customizable policy plans
  • Easy access to quotes
  • Get an insurance policy straight from your computer

Liberty Mutual

Insuring more than 1.5 million vehicles, Liberty Mutual has some of the top customer service ratings.

In J.D. Power’s 2018 Insurance Shopping Survey, Liberty Mutual was ranked “better than most” it the categories of Policy Offerings, Local Agents, and Insurer Website, a few of the company’s standout features.

  • 24-hour claims service
  • Accident forgiveness, new car replacement, better car replacement, deductible fund

Liberty Mutual can be expensive if you are purchasing a single policy.


High quality insurance with the opportunity for discounts. Allstate has the best of both worlds with brick and mortar offices and helpful websites. Allstate had highest ratings from customers who reported a good rental car experience.

  • Physical offices and local agents
  • Multiple opportunities for discounts
  • Customer-friendly website


USAA received a 5/5 overall customer satisfaction rating from J.D. Powers. Customers also were satisfied with their final settlement after an accident.

USAA is only available to members or former members of the United State military and their close family members.

  • Top ratings, great customer satisfaction
  • Diverse policy options

Quick Money Savings Tip For Safe Drivers

There are dozens of auto insurers – Which one will give you the best rate?

Step 1) Choose your vehicle make below.
Step 2) On the next page, complete the 4 minute questionnaire, and you'll have the opportunity compare the best rates in your area.
Step 3) Keep more money and possibly save hundreds!

1 Choose a make for potential car insurance discounts:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *